We were treated to one of the greatest bull markets in modern history during the last decade. It’s not that we didn’t experience selloffs. We did.
During 2011 and 2018, the S&P 500 Index came very close to entering a bear market (Yahoo Finance), which is typically defined as a 20% or greater pullback in the broad-based S&P 500 Index.
From its closing peak of 4,796.56 on January 3, the S&P 500’s most recent closing bottom of 3759.89 on June 22 translates into a peak-to-trough loss of 21.61% (MarketWatch).
What fueled the rise in stocks over the last decade and what has changed today? We believe there has been a shift in the economic fundamentals.
During the 2010s, interest rates were extremely low; the Fed was buying Treasury bonds during the early part of the decade (popularly called quantitative easing or QE); inflation was low; and the economy was expanding at a modest, if unimpressive, pace. That economic expansion fueled a rise in corporate profits.
When the Fed began to raise rates, the shift in policy was gradual.
While stocks never rise in a straight line, the economic fundamentals created a strong tailwind for equities.
A brief review of the data from Yahoo Finance shows that on December 31, 2009, the S&P 500 Index closed at 1,115. Ten years later, the S&P 500 had nearly tripled to 3,231. On May 31, it closed at 4,132.
On December 31, 2009, the Dow Jones Industrial Average closed at 10,428. It ended the decade at 28,538. On May 31, the Dow closed at 32,990.
What’s going on today
Today, the economy is expanding, and corporate profits are rising, according to Refinitiv. But an upbeat Q1 profit season failed to stem the latest slide in stocks. Why? We believe you can point to a shift in the once-favorable fundamentals.
First, let’s start with the Federal Reserve. During prior rate-hike cycles, such as the early 2000s and the second half of the 2010s, the Fed took great pains to reassure investors that increases would be “measured” or “gradual.”
The investor-friendly language has been jettisoned.
In hindsight, the Fed should have started tightening the monetary screws with rate hikes last year. It didn’t. It insisted that last year’s rise in inflation was “transitory.” It wasn’t.
In response to the sharp rise in inflation, the Fed is being forced to play catch-up.
In May, the Fed hiked its key lending rate, the fed funds rate, by 50 basis points (bp, 1 bp = 0.01%) to 0.75% – 1.00%. It was the first 50 bp rise in over 20 years.
Then after a surprisingly bad inflation reading for May, the Fed then made recent history again and hiked the fed funds rate by 75 basis points to 1.50%-1.75%. Another indication that the Fed is playing catch-up to get inflation back under control.
In an interview last month, Fed Chief Powell said, “What we need to see is inflation coming down in a clear and convincing way, and we’re going to keep pushing until we see that.” It’s tough talk.
We want a return to price stability, and comments like that strongly suggest job #1 at the Fed is price stability. But over the shorter term, an aggressive policy to rein in inflation increases economic uncertainty and angst among investors.
In addition to rate hikes, the Fed will also let some of the maturing bonds it holds run off its balance sheet without replacing them. It’s the opposite of QE, and it’s called QT—quantitative tightening. As with rate hikes, it’s a shift away from the Fed’s easy money policy.
While the Fed should take some responsibility for today’s high inflation, we won’t blame it entirely on them. Excessive fiscal stimulus encouraged a consumer-led buying binge (and a fast return to full employment), and supply chain woes that limited the availability of some goods are part of the problem, too.
Further, severe labor shortages have lifted wages, and businesses are passing along the higher costs.
Market volatility is also being exacerbated by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, which has pushed up energy and food prices and appears poised to slow global growth. Recent lockdowns in China have aggravated supply chain issues.
Lastly, whether it is warranted or not, odds of a recession have risen, which is adding to uncertainty.
Taking the stairs up and the elevator down
Stocks have a long-term upward bias, but downturns can be swift and uncomfortable. We understand that. But a review of the long-term data is encouraging.
The Schwab Center for Financial Research analyzed S&P 500 data going back to 1966.
While we know that past performance doesn’t guarantee future results, Schwab found that the average bear market lasted 446 days (including weekends/holidays). The average bear market decline was 38.4%.
Here is the good news. Bull markets averaged 2,069 days and returned an average of 209.2%.
Yet, history and data clearly show that market timing is exceedingly difficult.
“I never have the faintest idea what the stock market is going to do in the next six months, or the next year, or the next two,” legendary investor Warren Buffett once quipped. He’s right.
A few get lucky from time to time, but no one can consistently call market tops and market bottoms. Nonetheless, we believe that clarity on inflation and rate hikes would inject a more positive tone into sentiment.
That said, Buffett has an investment plan. He follows it, and he has an enviable track record. Buffet knows markets don’t rise without corrections.
His investment plan and your investment plan account for unexpected detours–you know, when markets take an unscheduled detour lower.
But your plan isn’t set in stone. As life’s circumstances change, the plan can and should be revisited. But let’s be careful about making investment decisions that are based on emotion.
As the plan discourages one from taking on too much risk when stocks are soaring (and we may feel invincible), it also discourages one from selling when the waters turn choppy.
Successful investors are disciplined. They avoid letting excess optimism or pessimism guide their decisions.
What can you do now?
When markets correct it can be confusing and frustrating. You have a good plan in place but what can you do to improve your situation? Here’s some ideas to consider.
1. Accelerate your IRA and retirement plan contributions. Why wait until the end of the year when you can make these contributions while the market is “on sale”?
2. Consider Roth conversions. A market decline essentially provides a tax break or opportunity, on top of the other amazing benefits of a Roth IRA. Don’t forget about Backdoor Roth conversions or even Mega Backdoor Roth conversions, either.
3. Reevaluate cash flow. With the market being down it’s time to make sure you know where your cash flow is coming from. Slow down (or stop) distributions from depreciated investments and allow them time to rebound. Consider alternative sources for major expenses like home equity lines of credit while interest rates are still low.
If retired or planning to retire, this step is essential. That’s why we’ve created our Definitive Guide to Retirement Income Planning to make sure everyone can get provide sustainable cash flow through retirement.
4. Rebalance your portfolio. Rebalancing is a “recalibrating” process that means selling overvalued or appreciated positions and rotating to areas that may have depreciated or you were hesitant to consider. This will help to keep your risk in check and position you for a rebound in the market. This is also a good time to evaluate your hedging strategies.
5. Start to invest the cash you have on the sidelines. We will only know after the fact whether the bottom is here, but there is a bottoming process going on. Consider dollar-cost averaging into the market with your cash and get in at a discount.
6. Tax-loss harvest in taxable accounts. With so many broad-based losses, consider tax-loss trading your losing positions to generate future tax savings. However, be aware of wash-sale rules when tax-loss harvesting.
7. Get more aggressive with your asset allocation strategy. If you have a long-term time horizon and the temperament to handle volatile markets this might be an option for you. This will likely be an outcome of any rebalancing as well.
We know times like these can be difficult. If you have questions or would like to talk, we are only an email or phone call away.